Essays

This Table Was Built for Us

For Jewish Readers

Aaron Asher · Published

In this essay
  1. I want more Torah
  2. Whose questions are we answering?
  3. Ramban and the earth
  4. When the explanation becomes the dream
  5. What did Torah promise to fulfill?
  6. Memory is not confirmation
  7. The work is not finished

I built this website because I want more Torah.

I want interpretations that make another passage readable. I want an observation in Genesis to remain useful when we reach Exodus, and a law in Deuteronomy to send us back to Genesis with something we had not understood before. I want to discover how much the Torah can explain about itself when we stop losing the information it has already given us. And I am willing to search our very large library to find the readings that help us do that.

That search reaches across thousands of years of Jewish learning. Talmud, midrash, the Geonim, and our classical commentators are central to the conversation here. We will also draw on ancient Jewish writings, the historical worlds of the ancient Near East and Second Temple period, philology, literary analysis, and source criticism wherever they help the Torah teach more Torah. Each can force us to notice something we might otherwise miss: a distinction obscured by translation, a question an ancient interpreter already recognized, a historical meaning we no longer hear, or a tension our preferred explanation makes disappear. An ancient reader need not be right for their question to matter. A modern explanation must still account for what the text says. The standard throughout is whether a source helps us see more of Torah without forgetting something Torah has already told us.

Our commentators have spent centuries noticing the Bible’s language, comparing its passages, and arguing over its difficulties. We inherit their observations alongside their disagreements. We can study how they reached an answer and ask whether the evidence they uncovered takes us further. Their conclusions are part of our inheritance; so is the work that allows us to examine them.

I am Jewish, and I built this website as a place for us to do that work together. Imagine a study table with Torah open in the middle and our commentaries within reach. Bring what you learned in yeshiva, in synagogue, at home, or through your own study. If you are beginning, you will learn how to enter the discussion. If you are a talmid chacham, this method will ask you to examine premises that years of learning can leave unexamined. Knowing a passage and its commentaries does not mean we have retained everything the passage established. There is more Torah to recover even in verses we can recite by heart.

This table was built for us and the fullness of our inherited tradition. What distinguishes the work we do here is how we choose and evaluate the interpretations we bring.

I am offering commentary that answers the Torah’s questions.

That may sound like a description of every commentary. It isn’t.

We can come to Torah asking how to live, how to understand suffering, how to defend our beliefs, or how a verse relates to a halakhah we already practice. We can seek an answer to a Christian argument, a response to a skeptical objection, or a way to reconcile a passage with something we believe must be true.

Those questions can generate substantial learning, and there are wonderful places to pursue them. Here, we begin by asking what the text itself has made necessary to explain. An explanation can leave us satisfied while leaving much of the Torah unemployed. The troubling phrase has been explained, the objection answered, and we move on. But the explanation may have given the surrounding verses no work to do, and the next chapter may be no more intelligible than it was before.

Consider what Ramban does with “Let us make the human” in Genesis 1:26.

He identifies the earth as God’s partner in making humanity: the body comes from the earth, while God supplies the spirit. His explanation draws on the earth’s already established role in bringing forth living creatures in Genesis 1:24 and looks forward to the human’s formation from the ground in Genesis 2:7. We can check those connections against the passages he brings, then ask whether keeping the earth in view continues paying off.

The human works the ground, returns to it, and finds the conditions of life altered through its curse. In the next generation, the ground receives Abel’s blood, and Cain’s relationship to it changes (Genesis 3:17–19; 4:10–12). These passages do not automatically prove Ramban’s identification of “us.” They give us an investigation his reading helps make visible. How much of the story becomes more intelligible when the earth retains the role Genesis has already given it?

An interpretation of one pronoun can return an entire participant to the story.

That is the kind of gift I am searching for in our commentators: an observation that keeps teaching us after the original difficulty has been addressed.

An interpretation that helps explain more than we were asking is paying rent. An answer that resolves a verse by making the surrounding story harder to understand has incurred a debt. An insight that illuminates the story has earned further investigation. We carry it into passages that seem to support it and passages that put it under pressure.

We widen the investigation until the interpretation breaks—or survives long enough to teach us more than we thought it would.

That standard applies to the same commentator from one passage to another. Ramban’s reading of the earth shows us what retaining a premise can recover. His reading of Joseph lets us examine whether a premise we have retained was established by the text at all.

A seventeen-year-old Joseph tells us his dreams. His family tells us what they mean. Sheaves bow to his sheaf; his brothers hear a claim to rule over them. The sun, moon, and eleven stars bow to him; Jacob supplies the family portrait: himself, Joseph’s mother, and the brothers (Genesis 37:7–10). We know the brothers eventually bow, so we read forward expecting the family’s explanation to come true.

Somewhere in our memory, their explanations became the dream.

Our commentaries can reinforce that expectation. Rashi notices that Joseph’s mother is already dead. He offers Bilhah, who raised Joseph, as a replacement maternal figure. He also invokes the rabbinic teaching that every dream contains meaningless elements.

Ramban objects to the identification with Bilhah. He uses the list of those who descend to Egypt to argue that she had already died too. He instead understands the moon as Jacob’s household and descendants (Rashi and Ramban on Genesis 37:10).

Watch what these explanations rescue. Rachel’s death threatens the identification of the moon with Joseph’s mother; Rashi supplies Bilhah as another mother. Ramban finds a further problem with that substitution but preserves the family interpretation by giving the moon a larger household to represent. The rabbinic principle about meaningless dream elements allows a mismatch to remain without overturning the reading. But invoking that principle does not settle whether Genesis warrants applying it to this dream.

Their explanations keep requiring further arguments to stay afloat. Before we follow those arguments any further, the method has an earlier question to ask:

When did we decide that the family’s interpretation was the thing the Torah had promised to fulfill?

Do we consider the brothers prophets? Do we think they regarded Joseph as one? Do the characters act as though these dreams are prophetic? And beneath those questions lies another: where did Genesis identify these dreams as a revelation from God?

The brothers’ conduct makes these questions immediate. They contemplate killing Joseph and seeing what becomes of his dreams (Genesis 37:18–20). They act as though removing the dreamer can dispose of the future they fear.

What do they think they heard: a revelation of God’s intention, or an announcement of Joseph’s ambition?

They can believe their brother wants to rule them without believing God has promised that he will. Their response may tell us what they resent about Joseph, rather than what they know about the future. We have been listening to their hostility as though it supplied prophetic insight.

Once we stop requiring them to be responding to prophecy, their behavior becomes brutally intelligible. They fear being subjected to Joseph. Selling him into slavery offers a way to make sure he cannot rule over them.

They have acted on their interpretation. We have treated it as prophecy.

If we read the dreams as prophecy, we must show how the narrative establishes that reading. We cannot place the conclusion at the beginning and then require every troublesome detail to accommodate it. The story itself gives us a standard of comparison in its treatment of other dreams.

The narrator confirms Joseph’s interpretations of the prison dreams and the arrival of the famine he predicts from Pharaoh’s dreams (Genesis 40:20–22; 41:54). It never supplies an equivalent declaration of fulfillment for Joseph’s childhood dreams. When the brothers eventually bow, it tells us that Joseph remembers those dreams (42:9). But reporting a character’s memory is not the same as confirming that a prophecy has come to pass.

We thought we were checking whether a prophecy came true. We may not have noticed how much of what we were checking was an interpretation supplied by characters within the story.

Follow the question through the full Joseph story: When Prophecy Comes True, Do We Still Get to Choose?.

In the Joseph story, Rashi and Ramban work to rescue the family’s interpretation. We can learn from the problems they noticed without inheriting the requirement to preserve the answer they started with. Their work makes those problems available for us to examine. The text does not owe their interpretation the premises it needs to survive.

That is what I want this table to make possible. With the earth, a commentator helps us recover information we had stopped carrying. With Joseph, examining our commentators helps us recover a question we had stopped asking. In both cases, we leave with more Torah available to us than we brought.

The Tanakh is our intellectual gift to the world, and we have spent generations studying, teaching, preserving, and arguing over what it asks of us. That inheritance gives us an extraordinary amount to work with. Bring our commentators and the learning you have received from them. We will ask what their explanations recover, what they require, and how far the text allows us to carry them. My proposals must answer those same questions.

Our commentators have given us centuries of work. The Torah has not told us that the work is finished.

This table was built for us to continue it.